March 17, 2010

Fact of Fiction: Waterproof Mascara is Bad For Your Lashes

For today’s head-scratcher I rang up makeup artist extraordinaire Suzy Martin for a professional opinion. She not only works with celebs and hot models, but is humble, hilarious, and my go-to for a super-fresh face that lasts all night. You can book her for a special event or just because at


Q:  Is waterproof mascara bad for your lashes? –Caitlin

A:  It is not as good for your lashes as (regular) water-resistant mascara for several reasons. First, the agents used to make it waterproof is drying to lashes. Second, it takes more effort to remove waterproof mascara, which can lead to excess rubbing and tugging on your lashes and delicate eye area. As an alternative, apply one coat of water-resistant mascara to act as a buffer, and top it with a coat of waterproof mascara to help seal the deal. When you remove the waterproof mascara, use something oily like Andrea EyeQ’s Makeup Remover Pads ($4 at drugstores), which break down the mascara nicely, and condition your lashes.

andreaEyeQThis weekly column features beauty advice from yours truly, with help from some of the brightest experts in the business. Whether you’re searching for the best bronzer or contemplating Botox, send questions to

  • Departments

  • Daily Reads

  • women-vector

    Hello lovelies! I'm Elizabeth Dehn, a beauty writer + lifestyle editor who's equally fanatical about lip gloss as juice cleansing. I live in Minneapolis with Mr. Bets and our white lab, Molly Thomas.

    read more

  • Mositure
  • Best of Minneapolis

    Palms down the best professional spray tan in the Cities: perfectly golden, long-lasting and reasonably priced. You'll never reach for the self-tanner again.
    The Glow Lounge
    Painless laser hair removal. Enough said. Also: where my sun spots go to die.
    The Metropolitan

    read more

  • Instagram